Chef Gerry Hayden, 1964-2015


One of the forces behind the latest revolution on the North Fork dining scene, chef Gerry Hayden died September 2 after living for four and a half years with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis.

Hayden, along with his wife, Claudia Fleming, and partners, Mike and Mary Mraz, opened North Fork Table & Inn in 2006. Nominated for the best chef, Northeast, award by the James Beard Foundation three times, he was a mentor to a flock of chef and service professionals that have gone on to populate the North Fork’s restaurants, winery tasting rooms and coffee roasteries. In effect, serving as an usher to our food and wine region as we know it today.

I first met Hayden in the ’90s when he was the chef at East Hampton Point and I was a waitress. It was a big catering operation, and at night, when we were breaking things down, he would take the mic left over from the band and do a Bobcat Goldthwait impression, cracking jokes that made the time move faster.

And last year in February, Slow Food East End held an event at Kontokosta Winery to raise money to help him and Claudia and their nonprofit, A Love Shared (after the letters ALS), provide money for research on the disease and help them cope with the cost of living with the disease. When Hayden accepted the first Carlo Petrini Award (named after the founder of Slow Food), he thanked the farmers, cooks, winemakers, brewers and food writers that helped to enrich the region. I was floored. He was that kind of thoughtful. Kevin Penner, former chef at Della Femina and 1770 House in East Hampton, first met Hayden 20 years ago, when Drew Nieporent owned Della Femina and East Hampton Point. Hayden was still working in the city at Park Avenue Café with chef David Burke. “He was a chef’s chef,” says Penner. “The one that did that part of dedicating yourself to farm to table and using whole animals; that’s what chefs do. He was endlessly creative.” After he retired—and Hayden was already ill—Penner worked in North Fork Table’s kitchen and helped conduct cooking classes called the Sessions, lessons that incorporated jazz into mise en place.

In addition, Penner says Hayden’s dedication to buying whole animals and breaking them down, while old school, added to the difficulty of maintaining continuity. “When you’re buying steers from McCall or sheep from 8 Hands or chickens from the Browders, you can’t depend on getting everything the same size. Somehow you’ve got to make it work.

“He was a chef’s chef,” says Penner. “There’s no doubt about it.”

While Hayden was sick, he was a regular, and sunny, presence on Facebook, where he detailed his trials and triumphs. Today, his page had become a memorial to the many he touched.

The restaurant will go on, says Mary Mraz. Dinner is still being served and Hayden’s recipes flawlessly executed. Services for family took place in September. Public services for the many who wish to pay respects are planned for October, says Mraz.